If President-elect Obama’s nominee to head the Federal
Communications Commission is looking for an opportunity to begin more closely
regulating network neutrality, he certainly has it at his disposal.
In a sternly worded letter, the FCC challenged Comcast, the U.S. largest
cable operator, to prove that it is not blatantly giving preferential treatment
to its own IP voice service over rivals such as Vonage.
The letter which was published by the FCC late Sunday is the
latest installment in a long running legal war between Comcast and two policy watchdog
groups.
The groups, Free Press and Public Knowledge, complained to
the FCC that Comcast impedes network performance of independent companies such
as VoIP firms that generate traffic on Comcast’s network.
The groups charge that Comcast is violating FCC rules by
throttling the performance of rivals while giving network preference to its own
competing applications. (Startups
Battle Comcast Over Video Blocking)
In February 2008 Comcast filed a rebuttal saying that it
manages traffic on its network so that its users don’t experience service
degradation. (Comcast Sues FCC)
Comcast said that it does not discriminate against any
particular class of content providers. All service providers are treated
equally.
In its letter the FCC calls on Comcast to explain a
discrepancy in its own advertising which says the Comcast’s VoIP service is not
subject to the network management which governs its rivals.
Giving its VoIP service an unfettered free pass while
subjecting rival services to possible performance degradation due to traffic
management adjustments goes against FCC regulations.
Comcast has until January 30 to explain the discrepancy.
Network neutrality, a broad fairness theory that says carriers should
not create separate performance tiers for certain streams of traffic over
others, has been a hot button issue for more than three years.
At least two network neutrality bills have died in Congress
because Democrats and Republicans generally come down on opposite sides of the
issue.
Free market Republicans do not see a need for separate
network neutrality regulation, preferring instead to allow market forces to
settle the issue. Democrats generally favor network neutrality regulation.
But with a larger Democrat majority in Congress, and a new
FCC chairman/nominee Julius Genachowski taking charge in Washington DC,
many expect network neutrality regulation to receive a more favorable hearing
on Capitol Hill. (Obama to Name
Former VC to Head FCC)
And the Comcast wrangle seems like a good place for Mr.
Genachowski, the first Democrat to head a Democrat-controlled FCC in eight
years, to enter the discussion.