The
wide-open business of advertising in online videos just got a little less
wide-open, as Google’s launch of in-video ads on YouTube has established a de
facto standard, validating an overlay format a number of startups had already
rolled out.
The ads
initially appear as translucent banners overlaid on the bottom portion of
videos. Viewers can click the overlays to pause the main video and replace it
with either a video ad
or an interactive Flash ad,
depending on the advertiser. Or they can click a button to make the banner
disappear, or simply ignore the banner, which will vanish after 10 seconds. If
they choose to click, they can bail out of the resulting video or interactive
ad at any time and return to the YouTube video they were originally watching.
Google’s
move addresses a problem that’s plagued the online video space: how to
advertise without driving away viewers. Hitherto the most common format, the
“preroll” ad, a long, television-style commercial tacked on to the beginning of
a video, had raised the ire of web surfers.
YouTube
had grown to be the leader in the online-video space in part because of its
ad-free format, and since buying the company Google had been cautious about
changing that model. But after extensive testing, Google thinks the new ad
formats are unobtrusive. Conscious of viewers’ distaste for preroll ads, Google
has arranged things so that the overlays appear no earlier than 15 seconds into
a video.
Startups
such as adap.TV, VideoEgg, ScanScout, and YuMe Networks—intermediaries that
bring video publishers and advertisers together—have found similar results with
alternatives to the preroll, recently introducing similar overlay ads. Google’s
endorsement of the overlay approach should provide assurances to the clients of
these startups.
For now
Google is selling ad space only in YouTube’s partner videos—that is, licensed
professional content. Unanswered is the question of whether YouTube will run
the new ads in user-generated videos. Advertisers have been wary of user
generated spots because of their unpredictability and the potential for violent
or offensive material. Along the same lines, Google will not sell space for the
new video ads by way of an auction format—an approach the company made famous with
its AdSense and AdWords programs. The ad space will be sold by a human sales
force.
ScanScout
CEO Doug McFarland said his company’s ability to safely place overlay-style ads
in user-generated videos differentiates it from YouTube. ScanScout’s
BrandProtector provides automated vetting of audio and video content to pull out
potentially negative material, Mr. McFarland said.
YouTube ads
that have run in the testing phase include spots for Universal Studios' Evan Almighty, Twentieth Century Fox's The Simpsons Movie, and NewLine's Hairspray. BMW has also been
represented, along with about 15 other companies, according to ClickZ. In
tests, the new ads have shown five to 10 times better click-through rates than
banner ads, YouTube said.
Google
will charge YouTube advertisers based on the number of people who see the
overlays, regardless of whether those viewers click on them. The company will
charge $20 per thousand views.